Hummingbird Heart ARC Review

Hummingbird Heart
By Robin Stevenson
Published by Orca Books
To be Published on April, 1 2012

Summary taken from Goodreads:

Sixteen-year-old Dylan has never met her father. She knows that her parents were just teenagers themselves when she was born, but her mother doesn't like to talk about the past, and her father, Mark, has never responded to Dylan's attempts to contact him. As far as Dylan is concerned, her family is made up of her mother, Amanda; her recently adopted younger sister, Karma; and maybe even her best friend, Toni.
And then, out of the blue, a phone call: Mark will be in town for a few days and he wants to meet her. Amanda is clearly upset, but Dylan can't help being excited at the possibility of finally getting to know her father. But when she finds out why he has come--and what he wants from her--the answers fill her with still more questions. What makes someone family? And why has her mother been lying to her all these years?

The cover:  I like this cover. I think it is simple and striking compared to other covers that are out on the market right now.  I like that it looks like a tattoo and that it ties into the story well.  I really have nothing negative to say about the cover- it is very pretty.  Another publisher (Penguin) has a YA title coming out this summer with a very similar cover, even the hummingbird tattoo.  I wonder if that is just  coincidence (it wouldn't surprise me).

The characters:  I really struggled with the characters.  I felt sympathetic for Dylan and for the struggles that she was facing, but I didn't like her very much.  To be honest, with the exception of Karma and Dylan's dad and his family- I didn't really like ANY of the characters.  It wasn't that they felt fake or flimsy- the characters were complete.  The choices that they made made me angry!  Every single character in this book was a "hot mess".  I was hoping that someone normal would come along and save me from the craziness.

The story:  I am incredibly conflicted about this story.  On one hand- I really did enjoy this story.  It was absolutely fascinating look at what it like for a girl to finally meet her real father after 16 years and the emotions that go through that meeting and developing a relationship.  But this is not the first book I have read where every single teen is smoking pot, getting high, getting drunk, and having sex every night.  Now I get that teens today are doing more, but really?  This book was EXTREME.  Am I really that disconnected from the world?  The way this book was written- it made it sound like if you were a virgin or someone who didn't get trashed or high you were abnormal.  Do I have any teen followers?  Is this really true? I admit, I am almost 30, but I really am tired about reading about teens that are train wrecks waiting to happen.  (But then again, maybe I am too stodgy).  There are numerous mentions of sex in this book, drug use is a prevalent theme, and there are many mentions of getting drunk and of alcoholics, and one pregnancy scare.  This was a good book, but not an uplifting one at all.


  1. Maybe that's just me, but I don't like birds on the covers too much...
    I haven't heard about this book before, but it doesn't sound too appealing. Thank you for the review!

  2. I agree, this cover is very pretty.

    I'll admit I drank on occasion in high school (and junior high - what a rebel), but not very often. But I was kind of a nerd, so maybe that is what the cool kids do... But since I'm 23, I am probably out of the loop.

  3. Although I was a nerd and didn't live a wild lifestyle as a teen, I had a few friends that were just your run-of-the-mill average Janes. Talking with themm and their friends, I got the feeling that sex, drinking and drugs did happen but not on some rampant scale.

  4. "Every single character in this book was a "hot mess"."

    This line made me laugh ! I feel this way about some books, I read. I may have to use this !

  5. I'm sorry you didn't like this one. :( The cover is lovely, the premise is great, but if you can't get behind the characters, it often ends up being more than a little bit disappointing.

    As far as the sex and the drugs . . . I'm going to be honest, YA books today aren't too far off with it. Of course, there are still many of us who prefer not to do either just yet, but it's, well, very common. Spoken as a high-schooler.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Child Finder

Back to the Books Giveaway Hop- Falling Under